A Hallmark Movies & Mysteries original movie. Crime Fiction Professor Amy (Jill Wagner) and Detective Travis (Kristoffer Polaha) attend a play where a prop gun fires a real bullet, narrowly missing the star Bella. Declaring the theater a crime scene, Travis has suspects galore, and luckily, he has Amy by his side who uses her expertise in whodunits. Together, they must uncover which character is playing for keeps before it is too late.